[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 14 September 2005, 13:38 GMT 14:38 UK
Viewpoints: UK fuel price protests
Campaigners staging three days of protests over UK fuel prices want the government to cut the duty of fuel.

But the government blames high prices on the cost of oil internationally, while environmental groups hope both factors will reduce oil consumption.

The BBC News website hears viewpoints surrounding the issue.

Karen Dee
Karen Dee, Road Haulage Association (RHA) director of policy

The difference in prices between ourselves and the rest of Europe causes a big problem in terms of competing.

That difference in price is principally tied with the duty rates that apply - our duty rate is far higher than anywhere else.

Fuel is typically a third of total business costs, so it has a big effect on the rates you have to charge to consumers.

The RHA wants to see the government take action to bring the duty more in line with the rest of Europe so that we are able to compete.

The second element is that the volatility in oil prices generally causes real problems in terms of business planning.

We believe the chancellor should take action - a 'fuel price regulator' would set a limit as the top rate for a barrel of oil.

If the price goes above that, it triggers a reduction in fuel duty to stabilise the price.

Mike Childs
Mike Childs, Friends of the Earth head of campaigns

Because of climate change, and a recognition that that is going to impact on millions of people round the world and devastate wildlife, we need to reduce our oil consumption and be more efficient in the way we use it.

That means greener cars, access to good quality public transport, and encouraging people to walk and cycle.

What we shouldn't be doing is sending people the reverse signal by reducing fuel prices.

If people buy more fuel-efficient vehicles they'll save much more than even if Gordon Brown was going to take 10p off the price.

We are less worried about whose pockets the money flows into, although if you are going to provide people with a high quality public transport service, the government needs money to do that.

Of course it's another challenge to make sure the money that flows into Gordon Brown's pockets does go into doing that.

HM Treasury logo
A spokesman for HM Treasury



As the chancellor has made clear, and European finance ministers recognise, the real issue is the international oil price which is a global problem requiring a global solution.

The chancellor has said: 'We are sensitive to the concerns of motorists right across the country at a time of doubling oil prices.

'The first action we will take is to tackle the cause of the problem - ensuring concerted global action is taken to bring down world oil prices and stabilise the market for the long term.'

It is worth noting that around half the fuel used in the UK bears little or no fuel duty, including the red diesel used by farmers, and the fuel used in industrial production, and the heating of homes and workplaces.

The chancellor also called for concerted action to increase the use of alternative sources of energy and greater energy efficiency - and for the World Bank to set up a new fund to support developing countries investing in alternative sources of energy and greater energy efficiency.

Currently duty differentials are in place to encourage the use of more environmentally friendly fuels.

Chris Hunt
Chris Hunt, UK Petroleum Industry Association director general

If road transport taxation is reduced, it will need to go up somewhere else, but our position is that setting levels of duty on fuel is a matter for the chancellor.

Whether that includes an element of taxation to encourage or discourage certain types of transport is a matter of government policy.

We manufacture petrol and diesel that is, pre-tax, the cheapest in Europe if not the developed world - taxation does put it up to among the most expensive in the EU.

I don't think you can say that taxation isn't an issue - fuel duty and VAT is 68-70% of the total pump price.

Gordon Brown is calling for more investment to go into production and refining, and we obviously would like to see investment in UK refineries, but the government has to create the right environment for that investment to happen in the UK.

If the regulatory environment for UK refineries, compared with EU refineries, is more punitive, companies are more likely to invest in a French or German refinery, say, than in the UK.




SEE ALSO:
Have you been buying extra petrol?
14 Sep 05 |  Have Your Say
Brown calls for oil price effort
13 Sep 05 |  UK Politics
Brown's fuel tax test
13 Sep 05 |  UK Politics
Dismay at Brown oil increase call
12 Sep 05 |  UK Politics
Brown blames fuel costs on Opec
11 Sep 05 |  Business
EU ministers urge oil output rise
10 Sep 05 |  Business


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific